Excellent
Based on 239 reviews
Coinfully4.8Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Selling your coins shouldn’t be frustrating – but often it is.Whether you’ve inherited a coin collection or collected rare coins yourself, you’ll want to make a smart financial decision when selling. But people are often disappointed by their options for selling a coin collection, having been misled by coin traders or fed inaccurate information on the internet. At Coinfully, we’re different. As life-long passionate coin collectors ourselves, we know how frustrating it is when you receive a low-ball offer for your prized coin collection – or maybe a rare coin you have inherited unexpectedly. That’s why we put educating coin sellers first, so you can have complete confidence in the decisions you make about selling your rare coins. We work with complete transparency and zero pressure so you can find out what your coins are really worth without stress.We take a modern approach to coin trading, embracing technology for our appraisals, network and transactions. This allows us to reach thousands more coin collectors around the globe online, while working cost efficiently. That way we can pay you more than traditional numismatic firms by passing on the benefits of our low overhead, so you always get the best price for your coin collection.Coinfully has been endorsed by numismatic experts. With decades of experience and storied careers in the coin industry, high profile coin collectors and numismatic authors recognize Coinfully offers a better way for people to have coin collections appraised – and this is all done from the comfort of the coin seller’s home.Coinfully is a family business, with family values that extend to our service. Led by brothers Travis and Wyatt McDonald, who have both worked for prestigious globally-recognised numismatic institutions, the pair created Coinfully’s ground-breaking business model. Coinfully exists to give the selling public a painless and honest way to value and sell coins simply online.Our 3-Step Clear Appraisal Plan ensures you get a ma
Coinfully (coinfully.com) has 239 customer reviews on Folks Told, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
Showing 224 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Robert P.
Very easy to get my coins appraised. Fast payment.
Reply from CoinfullyJun 7, 2026
Hi Robert, Thank you so much for sharing this! Easy and fast is what we aim for every time. Glad to deliver, and we're here whenever you need us! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
Stephen U.
Coinfully was a pleasure to work with: they offered me top notch service and value for my coin collection. They assisted me in every step of the sales process, paid for my shipping costs and issued my funds on the same day they received them. A special shout out to Braden for his truly excellent customer service!
Reply from CoinfullyJun 7, 2026
Hi Stephen, Thank you so much for the kind words and for the shoutout to Braden, this made his day! Assisting every step of the way, covering shipping, and issuing immediate payment upon receipt and verification are all things we take very seriously. Offering top notch service and best value are our #1 priorities. We'd be honored to work with you again anytime! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
Steve M.
I had 38 coins I received in a trade. I first looked at the selling price on EBay. If you’ve ever done business with eBay you already know they charge 13.6% then you need to constantly monitor your account and ship immediately. I read the reviews about Coinfully and decided to give them a try. Of course their offer was a little less than what I would’ve received on eBay. The following day I took my coins to a local coin shop dealer. The shop offered to pay me spot pricing on for example one coin that was valued at $1600.00. In essence they offered me $73.00 for the coin. After much consideration I emailed my contact at Coinfully. Listen these guys are polite, efficient and fair on thier offers. I would recommend this team of professionals to anyone 100%. The coins arrived today and by 4 PM the wire transfer was in my account. They even reimbursed my for the shipping cost. Great people, great service!!
Reply from CoinfullyJun 7, 2026
Hi Steve, Thank you so much for sharing this, and for doing the homework! We always encourage collectors to seek out multiple offers and this is exactly why. The fact that you compared options, weighed the trade-offs, and that you arrived at a decision you were comfortable with means a great deal to us. That's exactly the kind of informed process we want every collector to feel good about. The local shop experience you described is unfortunately not uncommon, and it's a big part of why we work so hard to make fair, transparent offers every time. We want to honor your responsive and open communication throughout the process. You didn’t hesitate to share your needs and that led to our understanding of how to help. It was our pleasure delivering a fast and seamless experience every step of the way. We'd be happy to hear from you again anytime! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
Jeffery C.
GREAT experience from beginning to end! I was looking to liquidate my late father's fairly large and varied coin collection. He had many coins from China, UK, and Canada, as well as US. Most were gold, some silver. I didn't trust any local shops to either have the knowledge, resources to pay, or ethics to handle it. I looked to larger cities near me but felt uneasy about transport and trust. I did a lot of research and came upon Coinfully. I did more digging into them and couldn't find any terrible reviews. Trustpilot score was high. I liked the idea that they would appraise the collection in my home. No transport/shipping worries. I sent some pictures of the "better" coins and received contact right away. An appointment was scheduled with Matthew. He arrived on time and appraised the collection and provided us with the value of the collection and the offer for the collection. The appraisement was slightly better with the research we had done on our own, and the offer was better than I expected, honestly. Payment arrangements were made for a wire transfer to my bank. Here's where it gets interesting, but it makes me want to give Coinfully kudos even more. There was an issue with the transfer to my bank (not a problem with anything Coinfully did). The bank was overly cautious of such a large transfer and sent me an email, but I did not see/respond to it soon enough. They rejected the payment. About the time was contacting the bank after I did see it, I got a call from Travis at Coinfully, saying the transfer was rejected and could we setup a different transfer to another bank. We did that, and the transfer went through without a hitch this time. To me, this speaks of Coinfully's integrity throughout this entire process. From start to finish I feel I was treated fairly, honestly, respectfully, and with integrity. I would not hesitate to recommend them, or avail of their services.
Reply from CoinfullyJun 7, 2026
Hi Jeffery, Thank you so much for taking the time to share this in such detail. The entire Coinfully team is so appreciative of your thoughtful words here. It was an honor to work with you and your father's collection. We understand how much trust it takes to invite someone into your home to appraise a collection of this significance, especially one with such important family history. You did your homework and we want to recognize the level of assessment and care you put into deciding to go with Coinfully. Collectors who come prepared and ask the right questions make for the best partnerships and that clearly showed throughout our entire experience with you. Our top priority is to do right by every collector we meet, so we really appreciate you sharing your experience here. Future collectors will appreciate hearing your story when they are doing their own digging and making similar decisions. Matthew and Travis really appreciate you calling out the wire transfer moment specifically because that's exactly the kind of situation where we want our character to show. When something unexpected happens, we believe the right move is always to pick up the phone and make it right. From our whole team to you and your family, thank you for your trust in Coinfully. We'd be honored to be of service again anytime! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
Michael K.
Very responsive to my request.
Reply from CoinfullyJun 7, 2026
Hi Michael, Thank you so much for sharing this! Responsiveness is something we work hard at every day and we always appreciate hearing about your experience with our service. We're here whenever you need us! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
Ted S.
Want to let others who might be selling precious metals know about the great experience I had with Coinfully. Beginning with their website, I experienced excellent communication, a fair appraisal and offer, clear documentation, immediate acknowledgement of receipt of my shipment, and finally same day wire proceeds. Can't say enough good things about them!
Reply from CoinfullyJun 10, 2026
Hi Ted, We really appreciate you sharing your experience here. Your note encouraging collectors to find us really hit home! Clear communication every step of the way is something we are truly dedicated to. From the first word you read on our website all the way through to payment confirmation, it means a lot hearing your confidence in us. We believe that the selling process should feel transparent, personal, and straightforward. Your feedback keeps us motivated. It’d be a treat to work with you again anytime! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
Melissa J.
I highly recommend working with Coinfully. I had several phone calls with various staff members prior to meeting with them. All were pleasant & helpful, leaving me with a strong sense that not only are they professional & knowledgeable but also respectful of my own perspective. Braden was so kind & knowledgeable, shared information & explained the “why.” Wyatt too was so helpful in this way. They most certainly made the daunting & emotional task of selling a coin collection much less daunting & even enjoyable. More like working in a partnership than a mere transaction.
Reply from CoinfullyJun 10, 2026
Hi Melissa, Your recommendation is priceless to us! Braden and Wyatt have shared recently that they remember those conversations fondly. We’re constantly learning how to get better, and the perspectives you shared helped us grow. It’s extremely important to us that we honor every collector’s unique experience and views. We feel kindness is woefully underrated in the coin world and we truly appreciate you reflecting your experience on the topic. Sometimes, it feels that being kind to one another is too easily brushed aside at the expense of business. For so many collectors, appraisals and the sale of collections is a deeply meaningful and emotional process which means a trusted partnership is worth its weight in gold. We believe every collector deserves to feel heard, respected, and honestly guided through the process. Hearing your note is the best feedback we could ask for. It would be our pleasure to hear from you again anytime! Thanks again, The Coinfully Team
Hannah D.
We couldn't be more grateful for finding Coinfully. We were at a complete loss as to how to successfully liquidate our coins given their location in the USVI. Upon talking with Wyatt and his team, we were immediately put at ease and knew that we had found exactly who we were looking for. From start to finish, they were professional, kind and honest. Our transaction couldn't have gone smoother. If we ever need their assistance in the future, we wouldn't use any other company - Coinfully would be our first and only call.
