Great
Based on 441 reviews
Bellevue Rare Coins4.4Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Bellevue Rare Coins has specialized in buying and selling coins, jewelry, gold, diamonds, and valuables since 1979. Four convenient locations to serve you!
Bellevue Rare Coins (bellevuerarecoins.com) has 441 customer reviews on Folks Told, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
Showing 342 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Andy
I was very impressed by the Tacoma store. I brought some coins from a small collection and recently walked in without an appointment. Christina was very helpful and incredibly knowledgeable. I would recommend the store to anyone who is looking to buy or sell coins.
Barbara
I'm a 76 year old woman who was a bit intimated coming in on my own. John immediately made me feel comfortable. The entire experience was so easy. Thank you John!
Leanne D.
I went to the Issaquah location and was helped by 2 gentlemen. I did not get the first man's name, but Steven Flanagan helped finish my transaction. Both men were very knowledgeable and thorough in their review of the jewelry, coins and flatwear that I brought in to sell. The transaction took 1 1/2hr to complete and it was near closing, but I never felt rushed. I have already contacted 3 friends and suggested they contact Steven for an appt. to bring in their valueables for review. Thank you.
Reply from Bellevue Rare CoinsSep 10, 2026
Hello Leanne, Thank you so much for taking the time to share such a detailed and thoughtful review! We know that sorting through a mixed collection of jewelry, coins, and flatware takes time, and we are honored that you chose our Issaquah team to help guide you through the process. Steven and the rest of our staff take immense pride in providing fair, transparent, and thorough evaluations, regardless of the clock. We are thrilled to hear that even near closing time, you felt completely respected, valued, and never rushed during your visit. Sending three personal recommendations to your friends is the highest compliment we could ever receive. We truly appreciate your trust and business, and we look forward to providing your friends, and you, on your next visit to Bellevue Rare Coins. Andrew G Regional Manager Bellevue Rare Coins
MS
Great, friendly service from Carina
Reply from Bellevue Rare CoinsSep 2, 2026
Hello MS, Thank you so much for the great review! We are thrilled to hear that Carina provided you with such friendly, top-notch service. As our Tacoma store lead, Carina sets a fantastic example for our team, and her dedication to taking wonderful care of our customers shines through every day. We will be sure to pass along your kind words to her, she will be delighted to know she made your visit so pleasant! Thank you for choosing Bellevue Rare Coins in Tacoma, and we look forward to welcoming you back on your next visit! Andrew G Regional Manager Bellevue Rare Coins
Nevada N.
I stopped in to get a new battery for my watch. The gentlemen working the store were polite, courteous, and professional. Very nice store with plenty of selection on precious metals and other things. I highly recommend them.
Reply from Bellevue Rare CoinsApr 6, 2026
Nevada Norton, Thank you for the high recommendation! We believe that every service, from a watch battery replacement to browsing our precious metals, deserves a professional and courteous touch. We’re so glad you enjoyed the store's selection and felt well-taken care of by our team. We look forward to seeing you again! Andrew G Regional Manager Bellevue Rare Coins
Thomas J.
Reyne Mack was very patient with my Mother and we both left feeling confident that he was friendly and cheerfull
Reply from Bellevue Rare CoinsApr 3, 2026
Dear Thomas, Thank you so much for sharing this! We are so glad to hear that Reyne took such great care of you and your mother. Patience and a positive attitude are qualities we value deeply, and we’ll be sure to share your kind words with Reyne, it will make his day! Andrew G Regional Manager Bellevue Rare Coins
Tim H.
Carina, in the Tacoma store, was so amazing and patient. I brought in a lot of silver and some gold jewelry that I never wore and I was able to sell almost everything. It’s a good feeling to have finally done this after waiting a long time to go on in! I’m so fortunate to have been able to work with her. She is excellent! Now I’m certain everyone there is wonderful but I will be going back to see her when I’m ready to sell more jewelry. Carina took the time to look over all the pieces. There was no sense of rushing through this process, at all. This was a positive and nice experience! All my thanks!!
Reply from Bellevue Rare CoinsMar 16, 2026
Dear Tim, Thank you so much for the kind words! We are thrilled to hear that you had such a positive experience working with Carina. Selling jewelry can feel like a big step, especially when you’ve been holding onto pieces for a long time, so we’re glad she could provide the patience and care you deserved. Carina is indeed a gem, and she’ll be so happy to hear that her thoroughness made your visit stress-free. We look forward to seeing you again whenever you're ready for your next 'decluttering' session. Enjoy that great feeling of a job well done! Andrew G Regional Manager Bellevue Rare Coins
customer
Once again, I had an outstanding experience at Bellevue Rare Coins. Krisitie helped me this morning and she is terrific- knowlegable, helpful, and friendly. It was a pleasure doing business with her. Without a doubt, I will go there again! I had an appointment booked for tomorrow, but did a drop in around 11 a.m. and only had to wait a bit less than a half hour.
Reply from Bellevue Rare CoinsMar 6, 2026
Good Morning, It was so good to have you back! We are thrilled that Kristy was able to assist you this morning, she truly is terrific and loves sharing her knowledge with our regular customers. We’re also glad the 'drop-in' worked out so well for you! Thank you for the loyalty and the kind words; we’ll be sure to pass them along to Kristy. Thank you again for your great review and we hope to see you next time! Andrew G Regional Manager Bellevue Rare Coins
