customerDaniel S.
Rapid response to questions
Rapid response to questions. Ease of conducting inventory inspection. Pick-up of items being sold removed issues of shipping, etc. Overall, a good process.

Excellent
Based on 239 reviews
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Selling your coins shouldn’t be frustrating – but often it is.Whether you’ve inherited a coin collection or collected rare coins yourself, you’ll want to make a smart financial decision when selling. But people are often disappointed by their options for selling a coin collection, having been misled by coin traders or fed inaccurate information on the internet. At Coinfully, we’re different. As life-long passionate coin collectors ourselves, we know how frustrating it is when you receive a low-ball offer for your prized coin collection – or maybe a rare coin you have inherited unexpectedly. That’s why we put educating coin sellers first, so you can have complete confidence in the decisions you make about selling your rare coins. We work with complete transparency and zero pressure so you can find out what your coins are really worth without stress.We take a modern approach to coin trading, embracing technology for our appraisals, network and transactions. This allows us to reach thousands more coin collectors around the globe online, while working cost efficiently. That way we can pay you more than traditional numismatic firms by passing on the benefits of our low overhead, so you always get the best price for your coin collection.Coinfully has been endorsed by numismatic experts. With decades of experience and storied careers in the coin industry, high profile coin collectors and numismatic authors recognize Coinfully offers a better way for people to have coin collections appraised – and this is all done from the comfort of the coin seller’s home.Coinfully is a family business, with family values that extend to our service. Led by brothers Travis and Wyatt McDonald, who have both worked for prestigious globally-recognised numismatic institutions, the pair created Coinfully’s ground-breaking business model. Coinfully exists to give the selling public a painless and honest way to value and sell coins simply online.Our 3-Step Clear Appraisal Plan ensures you get a ma
Coinfully (coinfully.com) has 239 customer reviews on Folks Told, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
239 approved reviews, newest moderated first
customerDaniel S.
Rapid response to questions. Ease of conducting inventory inspection. Pick-up of items being sold removed issues of shipping, etc. Overall, a good process.
James D.
Coinfully was a great experience. They were easy to deal with, very knowledgeable, and quick to respond to my request including several changes. They processed the list I sent them and sent me a fair appraisal. Once I shipped the coins, I was paid the same day they arrived by e-check.
Mike S.
Braden was a pleasure to work with. His communications were promt and clear. The offer was fair. I asked him to make several adjustments during the offer process, and he came through right away every time. The shipping had me nervous, but after Braden explained it to me, I felt much more comfortable, and it made the transaction easy. I received a check via email right away after my collection was received and reviewed. I would DEFINITELY recommend Coinfully to anyone looking to sell a coin collection.
David W.
Coinfully made the process quick and easy.
Coinless
BRADEN WAS SUPER RESPONSIVE AND GAVE US A GOOD DEAL!
Vincent
Quick response. Fair offer to buy. Very pleased. Will probably do business with them again.
Kim W.
Coinfully made this such a painless process. Matt was wonderful and answered all y questions in minutes. I highly recommend Coinfully for anyone looking to sell.
Benjamin S.
I submitted and got paid a fair price for my first shipment. It was so easy....the hardest part was inventorying them. But today, I learned that there were two counterfeit coins in my shipment of 40 or so coins. I was told by the person I was dealing with (nice guy) that "After speaking with my boss about the coins he informed me that due to our insurance policy once we receive a package with counterfeit items we are no longer allowed to receive packages from that client and be covered." I find this policy to be offensive. They weren't out anything as they're returning the two counterfeits to me.
Reply from CoinfullyJul 25, 2024
Hi Benjamin, While we are happy you had a great experience selling your coins, we completely understand the frustration with not being able to sell to us a second time. Please do not take this to be a judgement on you or your collection. Counterfeit items are commonplace in the numismatic hobby and our team is skilled in their identification. That said, we have very strict policies that we follow pertaining to security and insurance that enable us to offer our modern approach to coin appraisals to the widest possible audience. We deeply appreciate you sharing your experience on this matter so that we can continue to improve our offerings every day.