Average
Based on 1,396 reviews
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Over 250,000 happy customers!
Gatsbyshoes (gatsbyshoes.co) has 1,396 customer reviews on Folks Told, with an average rating of 3.1 out of 5.
1,396 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Hermione V.
Shoes are great! Come as ordered and in good condition! Customer support is quick to respond, professional, and helpful!
Reply from GatsbyshoesDec 24, 2025
Thank you for sharing such kind words, Hermione. We will continue to deliver the level of support you have come to expect from us. -The GatsbyShoes Team
Michael
The advertisement shows brown shoes with black toe for sale. Upon arrival the shoe only shows brown, no classy black highlight. It seems bait and switch to me. If I can get the one advertised, I would like to. Also now I find out that you’re charging me shipping when you have free shipping advertised. This is not a good experience. I like my other pairs, but this one has started out all wrong.
Reply from GatsbyshoesDec 26, 2025
Hello Michael, We apologize for any inconvenience you may have encountered. We have reached out via Trustpilot regarding your order information to provide assistance promptly, but unfortunately, we have not received a response. Should you require further assistance or have additional concerns, please do not hesitate to contact us at [email protected] -The GatsbyShoes Team
Brian B.
Informative. And courteous. I would however have liked an eta on the refund.
Reply from GatsbyshoesDec 26, 2025
Hi Brian, Thanks for sharing your experience on how we have handled your concern. Please be advised that returns typically take 1 to 2 weeks for our warehouse team to thoroughly check and inspect the item(s). Once the inspection is complete, we will promptly process your refund, and you will receive an email confirmation. We appreciate your patience and understanding during this process. If you have any further questions, please don’t hesitate to reach out! -The GatsbyShoes Team
Hanan C.
Shoes are Not Leather website is deceptive. They are crappy plastic that stink lie chemicals. DO NOT GET THESE
Reply from GatsbyshoesDec 26, 2025
Hi Hanan, We sincerely apologize for not meeting your expectations. We strive to provide high-quality products to all our customers, and we regret this experience. Our records indicate that your return-for-refund request has already been approved. Once we receive the returned product, we will promptly process your refund in accordance with our policy. Thank you for your patience and understanding. Please feel free to reach out if you have any further questions or concerns. -The GatsbyShoes Team
Louie G.
Great shoes.
Reply from GatsbyshoesDec 7, 2025
Hi Louie, Thanks for sharing your feedback about how great our products. -The GatsbyShoes Team
Bill A.
My first pair of Gatsby shoes were great but that unfortunately was not the case with the second and last pair. That second pair were too tight so I requested an exchange for half size larger. I was told it would cost me another $30
Reply from GatsbyshoesDec 26, 2025
Hello Bill, We’re sorry to hear that the shoes did not fit as expected. As discussed during your recent contact with us, your order was fulfilled in accordance with the style and size you selected on our website at the time of purchase. We would also like to clarify that our refund policy is presented during the checkout process and specifies that return shipping fees are the responsibility of the customer. We apologize if this information may have been overlooked. We understand that a return fee may be incurred for returning the shoes. However, this information was clearly disclosed during the checkout process. We appreciate your understanding and hope to have the opportunity to regain your trust in the future. -The GatsbyShoes Team
SMC
I bought Gatsby shoes in December 2024. I wear them on Sunday so they still look like new. The front of the sole separated from the shoe. There are no signs of any adhesive that bonded the sole to the shoe. I sent a message and pictures to customer support. They responded that my concerns were noted but fell outside of their 6-month window. I found their staff to be inflexible and pandering with their comments. My shoes clearly had a manufacturing issue and Gatsby didn't care. I don't recommend Gatsby to anyone.
Reply from GatsbyshoesDec 9, 2025
Hi Stephen, We're truly sorry about your shoes. As it falls outside our refund and exchange policy, we regret that an exchange request can not be granted. -The Gatsbyshoes Team
Christopher W.
I owned shoes for 7 months and wore 8 times. Soles fell off shoe . When I reported , your advisor said „sorry, only 6 month warranty. Your shoe is obviously garbage.
Reply from GatsbyshoesDec 26, 2025
Hello Christopher, Thank you for reaching out to us, and we apologize to learn that the sole has separated from your shoes. We understand that footwear may develop signs of wear over time due to regular use. Our records confirmed that the shoes unfortunately fall outside our exchange period. To learn more, kindly visit https://gatsbyshoes.co/pages/refund-policy. I hope you understand that, in this situation, our policy stands. Thanks for your understanding. For other questions or concerns, please don't hesitate to contact us! -The GatsbyShoes Team
