Bad
Based on 46 reviews
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Goldin is listed under Gaming.
Goldin (goldin.com) has 46 customer reviews on Folks Told, with an average rating of 1.3 out of 5.
46 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Steve
I attempted to consign $100,000 worth of rare PSA Pokemon cards, but got ignored. I received one email right away from one of the Netflix “stars” but after that, he ignored me. I followed up a few times, but then gave up and moved on to Heritage and they’ve been amazing so far.
Shane W.
Terrible communication and customer service.
Tim C.
I have been an eBay member for almost 30 years and Goldin auctions live was a exhilarating experience. It brought back the experience of sitting in a live auction house. Coleman was top notch at showing and describing everything. Can't wait for their next live Star Wars auction, I'll be watching and bidding.
Tyler C.
1 Star – Extremely Disappointing Experience If you’re considering working with Goldin Auctions, I strongly suggest thinking twice. At Collect-A-Con ATL February 6, Alex Fung approached my table about a DBZ slab I had priced at $12,000. He told me he could get that price and that the buyer would cover all fees. Based on that, I trusted him and handed over my card. What he did NOT tell me was that the slab wouldn’t even be listed for an entire month. That lack of transparency cost me thousands of dollars. Had I known there would be a delay, I would have sold the card on the show floor for around $10,000 without hesitation. Instead, during that month-long delay, the market fluctuated heavily—from about $14K down to $8K—and somehow my card ended up selling for $5,400… the lowest sale this slab has seen in months. That’s not bad luck—that’s poor decision-making. To make matters worse, the card was listed alongside a Black Label slab, which obviously drew the serious buyers away. Anyone in this space knows that directly hurts the final sale price. From start to finish, this was a terrible experience. Communication was poor, expectations were misrepresented, and the end result speaks for itself. I would not trust Goldin with another card.
Peterdrumtom
Horrible owner
Nathan S.
Writing this review because buyer from Australia 🇦🇺 and these idiots wont even let me bid after giving my licence and credit card
Steven
I have sent them a list, 3 times, of about 50 vintage BGS graded baseball cards I would like to auction. It's been two months since I sent the original request. I got a response saying they received my list but have not heard from anyone. My take is they are not as professional of a auction house as they advertise they are. This list of cards are just the first of 100's I have to auction. So seller be ware, as I now don't feel comfortable sending them the cards when they can't even response to the initial request.
Ben
Do not trust this site on buying items. Fees were not accurately described on the site when bidding. The description of items were also not clear. Do not trust this site.
