Great
Based on 52 reviews
Indy Auto Man Car Dealership4.4Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Indy Auto Man Car Dealership in Indianapolis, Indiana offers all cars with a 7-day exchange and 30-days price match guarantee. Car lot is located in Indianapolis, few blocks from I-465, exit 2A. Greenwood and Beech Grove are close by our used car dealership. If you are looking for a “used car dealer in Indianapolis” - you found it! Buy used car, truck, or SUV and sell your old car to Indy Auto Man - one of Indianapolis best car dealers. Indy Auto Man, Indianapolis car dealership, located near Greenwood and Beechgrove, offers a transparent and efficient used car buying experience with a wide selection of over 300 cars on-site and online. We prioritize transparency, providing free CARFAX reports and allowing third-party inspections. Every car undergoes comprehensive service and reconditioning to ensure safety and driveability. We offer extended warranties, a responsive customer service form, and weekly quality checks. Indy Auto Man is committed to community outreach, supporting local families and sponsoring Indy Arts Fest. Our directors, who are immigrants themselves, are passionate about giving back. They aim to provide a franchise-like experience at an independent dealer price, focusing on transparency, value, and customer satisfaction. Choose Indy Auto Man for a trusted and community-driven car buying experience.
Indy Auto Man Car Dealership (indyautoman.com) has 52 customer reviews on Folks Told, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
52 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Dennis D.
Great experience selling our car to Indy Auto Man. Victor was transparent throughout the entire process. No pressure and he openly offered advice on alternative options if we had decided otherwise. Of all the auto deals I've done, buying or selling , new or used, this was the best experience and largely due to Victor's professionalism. We ended up with a deal that I genuinely believe couldn't be matched.
Karol C.
Worked with Victor to sell my vehicle. Fast, fair and no pressure. The Westfield location is really nice and staff are professional.
Matt C.
Sold my RAM 2500 truck to Victor for a great price. He was great to deal with. I would Recommend 👍
L.A.
Breeanna Lewis and Jocelyn were very helpful in helping me secure my next vehicle and the process was a smooth transition.
Nathan T.
Lorrainne and Austin were great!! The whole process was very straightforward and wrapped up within an hour. Value placed on my vehicle was fair and I would definitely recommend getting I touch if you’re looking to sell, trade or purchase.
Myron J.
UPDATE: 8/6/2026 Two weeks later and sitting on a lemon 🍋. Asked warranties, pushed for gap which don’t kick in until 25-30 days. Paperwork signed that the vehicle was mechanically sound, which was elaborated three different times to me while signing that piece of paperwork which miraculously wasn’t in my copy of the paperwork. Not only was that emphasized about being a mechanically sound once being in finalized with the lady who was taking care of the end process, she kept stressing something about a transmission issue may happen down the road so you may want some coverage or something almost implying that there is an existing issue. They’ve not been helpful, playing phone tag and not responding for days after manager said they would “ trade me out,” not trade in the junk I was sold. The issue still exist with no resolve from anyone I’ve tried to contact for a week and the Mechanic that I have looking at it said the transmission was a Band-Aid basically to last a couple months. The issue had already been there prior and had to be known. Still no resolve after phone tag for a week talking to sales manager finally who has employees in the background laughing at the financial burden they’ve placed on me. In the recording of the call not once did they deny knowing about the transmission issue instead talked around. Further actions will now be taken for lack of help from this business.
Ray B.
On March 16 2026 I purchased a 2020 Toyota Prius from Indy Auto Man Indianapolis via an internet-only sale executed by DocuSign. Multiple times the dealer represented the vehicle as having passed a thorough inspection, being mechanically sound, and having a "clean Carfax." Since taking delivery of the vehicle a week after the sale was completed online, multiple competent mechanics and technicians confirmed severe corrosion and structural failure in the rear suspension, as well as dangerous tire wear noted by the inspectors that risked the rear tires blowing out due to the undisclosed structural damage. I have paid approximately $8,000 so far for repairs to damage that should have, in my opinion, been either repaired or disclosed honestly prior to the sale. All mechanics who have inspected the damage and corrosion have stated unequivocally that there is absolutely no way this level of damage and corrosion could have been missed by even a cursory visual and mechanical inspection by a competent inspector or mechanic. Via certified mail I have demanded sale rescission, all pre‑sale inspection records for this vehicle, and reimbursement for repairs required to correct the significant unrepaired and undisclosed damage that existed prior to sale; the dealer has so far not produced the requested inspection records, has refused my requests for remedy through sale rescission, and has refused to reimburse all costs I've had to pay out of pocket to correct the damage and corrosion that existed prior to purchase. I have filed an Indiana Attorney General complaint, AG Case #11837454, as well as complaints with the Better Business Bureau of Indiana, the Federal Trade Commission, and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. I have and can provide photos, repair invoices, DocuSigned sales records, and certified mail receipts for all complaints, remedy requests, and pre-sale inspection document requests. If you are in the Indianapolis area and are considering buying a car from this dealer, please undertake the expense of having any car you're considering buying inspected by a reputable and skilled 3rd-party mechanic or technician. Do not assume that the vehicle has actually been inspected, or that it is safe and roadworthy based solely on the statements of the dealership staff. If you are considering purchasing a car from out of state, I would caution against doing so based upon my documented personal experiences. I welcome a response from the dealer and will update this review if they remedy the situation.
Betty S.
We came to Indy Auto Man after visiting several other car lots. Bree was the 1st salesperson who actually listened to what we were looking for and our price range. She helped us find the car that checked most of the boxes and was a good deal. She also kept us informed throughout the process of getting the car ready. Thanks Bree!
