Reply from PetScyMay 18, 2026
Hey Denise,
Thanks for reaching out. I always like helping customers find the best option possible.
I reviewed your account and see that you have been ordering the 2-pack subscription option every month, which comes out to about $28.50 per bottle. There is definitely a better value available for you.
We currently offer a 6-pack under the One-Time Purchase option for $155 total, which brings the cost down to about $25 per bottle. We previously offered this under the subscription section as well, but too many customers focused only on the savings and overlooked the subscription aspect, resulting in customers unexpectedly receiving another 6 bottles 30 days later and becoming frustrated.
Because you have been a long-time customer, I would also be happy to apply an additional $20 discount to your first 6-pack order, bringing your total down to $135 plus tax, or roughly $22 per bottle.
Your next 2-pack subscription order was scheduled to process next week, but I pushed it back by one week so we could figure out the best solution first. If needed, I can always move the billing date again to whatever works best for you.
Here are the best options moving forward:
• Option 1 — 6-Pack One-Time Purchase
$135 plus tax after your ONE TIME DISCOUNT.
Approximately $22 per bottle
Best overall value
• Option 2 — 3-Bottle Subscription
$75 total
Approximately $25 per bottle
We can adjust delivery from every 30 days to every 40–45 days
• Option 3 — Reordering Support
You can:
Reorder directly through PetScy.com using the One-Time Purchase toggle
Contact me through reviews
Or I can provide my personal email for direct assistance
Also, was the 3-star review mainly because of the price? I would also love to hear how the Itch & Allergy Plus Chews have been helping your dog.
Have you noticed any recent differences in taste or effectiveness? We actually upgraded the formula recently. It still contains the same core ingredients, but we increased the Quercetin and added Colostrum.
Quercetin acts as a natural antihistamine and helps reduce itching, paw licking, redness, and inflammation caused by allergies. Colostrum helps support and regulate the immune system over time, which is important because many allergy issues in dogs are tied to immune system overreactions. We also adjusted certain ingredients to improve palatability.
Let me know your thoughts or if you have any questions.
Thanks,
Chris
Founder