Reply from SwissWatchExpoSep 22, 2026
Hi Claudia,
We saw your reviews related to the Rolex Oyster Perpetual watch that you purchased and wanted to reply to each of the elements in your review in turn.
You are correct that we initially sent the Certificate of Authenticity with an incorrect serial number, where one digit was entered incorrectly. This is clearly an error on our part - a human error that can in no way be construed as "fraudulent" and one which we were quick to address. In fact, after speaking with Kate on our team regarding this issue, you sent us the following note, "It was nice speaking to you today and thank you so much for all of your help with this matter - I sincerely appreciate it!"
At this point, your issue with the Certificate had been resolved, and you had now owned the watch for more than 10 days, removed the red inventory control tag, and resized the watch — all of which make this watch ineligible for a return.
However, you then sent us notes several days later claiming that while the lume works perfectly on the hour markers it doesn't on the hands, so you now want to exchange the watch for something different - but then almost immediately afterwards, you sent more notes demanding a full return. This is a 25+ year old watch, and it is well known that the real-world experience of the lume brightness may not last long before becoming a very faint, ambient glow — especially on the application to the hands which is an extremely narrow strip. It also matters how you charge it - flashlight vs. sunlight, where the latter is definitely better.
And then you sent even more notes saying that you would "gladly remove both reviews if this matter is resolved via a return / full refund. For the record it was always my intention to do so." So that's where we are right now. And to be clear, demanding a benefit, refund, or service in exchange for removing a negative review is widely defined as "review extortion" or "feedback extorsion" by most major platforms and business bureaus.
Given all of the items above, we are not moving forward with a return or exchange. This is a great watch, and we hope that you enjoy it for many years.
-- The SwissWatchExpo Team