Excellent
Based on 174 reviews
The Old School Game Vault4.9Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
The Old School Game Vault is a nationwide mail-in retro video game buyer and online store that has helped gamers, collectors, and families sell their old games and consoles since 2008. With an A+ BBB rating and more than 22,000 titles in its buying database, OSGV is a trusted way to turn retro games into cash.Founded by Brandon Perton, who grew up playing the original Nintendo NES, we buy games, consoles, and accessories for Nintendo, Sega, PlayStation, Xbox, Atari, and handheld systems. Customers build an order online, ship their items, and receive cash instead of store credit. Orders over $100 get a free prepaid shipping label, and payment is issued within 3 to 4 business days after we receive and process the order.Our online store sells tested, authentic games and consoles, with photos of the exact item customers will receive, including its condition and any flaws.Brandon also shares his experience through game reviews, counterfeit identification articles, and videos showing how our buying service works. We are BBB Accredited with an A+ rating.
The Old School Game Vault (theoldschoolgamevault.com) has 174 customer reviews on Folks Told, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
174 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Todd H.
Great experience. Selling my TG16 system and games could not have been easier. I submitted my order on the OSGV website and got a confirmation email with shipping instructions and label. Once OSGV received my system the receipt and payment were sent via Zelle promptly. A friend said it was too good to be true. But it is true. I highly recommend Brandon and the Old School Game Vault.
kelly W.
Super simple and fast turn around. Will definitely being doing business again.
Reply from The Old School Game VaultOct 11, 2026
Awesome, Thank you Kelly for taking the time to leave a review. Brandon
DALE L.
The experience couldn't have gone better. Through the website, I knew up front the value of each game. Submitted a request to sell to The Old School Game Vault (OSGV) and received a quick response with instructions and prepaid shipping. Once OSGV received shipment, it was processed within two business days. I received payment the following day via Zelle.
Reply from The Old School Game VaultSep 10, 2026
Thanks Dale, for taking the time to leave a review.
Karen
Very positive experience with selling our old games to Old School Game Vault. Easy to follow instructions. Highly appreciated Brandon's timely communication at each stage of the process: shipping, receiving, product review, and payment. Never left guessing or wondering. Customer service was top notch. Very nice surprise.
Reply from The Old School Game VaultJul 10, 2026
Thank you, Karen! I appreciate you taking the time to write this review, and I hope we can work together again in the future! - Brandon
Ryan D.
Sold my old video games on this website. The process was easy to use, and the staff was friendly and responsive to my questions. I received payment very quickly after being notified that my package had arrived at their location. I’d recommend The Old School Game Vault to anyone looking to sell their old video games or gaming consoles!!
customer
Good communication throughout the process. No issues.
Karen S.
All around great experience. Quick response, process straight forward and simple. Payment received in a timely manner for the exact amount quoted. I wasn't sure what to expect but I will use again if I have games to sell
Iris H.
I have sold a number of items to The Old School Game Vault and they have never disappointed me. My recent experience with the Old School Game Vault in January 2026 was also a success. This company is honest, fair and trustworthy. After receiving the items, payment is within a few days. The company also communicates very well and keeps the seller informed about every step. I highly recommend selling your old games and systems to the Old School Game Vault (A+ rating from me).
